In the world of smart home devices, Amazon’s Echo Show lineup stands out as a top contender. These devices combine Alexa’s voice assistant with a touchscreen display, making them ideal for video calls, streaming, smart home control, and more. Two of the most popular models are the Amazon Echo Show 5 and Echo Show 8. But how do they compare? And which one is the better choice for your needs?

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the Amazon Echo Show 5 vs 8 debate, covering everything from design and display to sound quality, features, and price.

1. Design & Display

Echo Show 5:

• Display Size: 5.5 inches
• Resolution: 960 x 480
• Compact and space-saving
• Available in multiple colors

Echo Show 8:

• Display Size: 8 inches
• Resolution: 1280 x 800
• Larger and better for media consumption
• Sleek, modern design

Verdict: The Echo Show 8 offers a much larger and clearer screen, ideal for watching videos, browsing photos, and making video calls. The Echo Show 5 is better suited for bedside tables or tight spaces where screen size isn’t a priority.

2. Audio Performance

Echo Show 5:

• Single 1.6-inch speaker
• Adequate for voice responses and background music
• Lacks bass and clarity at higher volumes

Echo Show 8:

• Dual 2.0-inch neodymium speakers
• Richer, fuller sound
• Better for streaming music or podcasts

Verdict: The Echo Show 8 easily outperforms the 5 in terms of audio. If sound quality matters to you—whether for music, audiobooks, or calls—the Echo Show 8 is the clear winner.

3. Camera & Video Calls

Echo Show 5:

• 2 MP camera (2023 model improved from 1 MP)
• Manual camera shutter for privacy
• Decent for basic video calls

Echo Show 8:

• 13 MP camera with auto-framing
• Better clarity and angle adjustment
• Ideal for frequent Zoom or Alexa video calls

Verdict: The Echo Show 8’s upgraded camera is a game-changer, especially for users who make regular video calls. The auto-framing keeps you centered, even if you move.

4. Smart Home Integration

Both devices offer excellent Alexa-powered smart home control:

• Voice control for lights, thermostats, and cameras
• Routines, timers, and reminders
• Visual display of smart home devices

However, the larger screen on the Echo Show 8 makes it easier to view security camera feeds, control settings, and interact with your smart home visually.

Verdict:

amazon echo show 5 vs 8

Both are competent, but the Show 8’s interface is more user-friendly thanks to its larger display.

5. Features & Functionality

Echo Show 5:

• Compact alarm clock-like design
• Best for bedrooms or small desks
• Affordable price
• Great for quick info, news, or checking the weather

Echo Show 8:

• More immersive experience
• Better for streaming content (Netflix, Prime Video, YouTube)
• Great for family use in kitchens or living rooms

Verdict: If you’re looking for a full-featured smart display, the Echo Show 8 wins again. But if you just want a simple, compact screen for your bedroom or office, the Show 5 will do just fine.

6. Price & Value

• Echo Show 5 (2023): Around $89.99 (often discounted to $49.99)
• Echo Show 8 (2023): Around $129.99 (discounts may bring it to $89.99 or $99.99)

Verdict: The Echo Show 5 offers great value for those on a budget or seeking a secondary device. However, the Echo Show 8 provides significantly more value in terms of performance, features, and overall experience, especially when on sale.

7. Privacy & Security

Both devices include the following privacy features:

• Physical camera shutter
• Microphone and camera on/off buttons
• Customizable privacy settings via the Alexa app

Amazon has made efforts to increase user control over data and recordings, and both models reflect this commitment.

8. Use Cases

Final Verdict: Amazon Echo Show 5 vs 8

Choose the Echo Show 5 if:

• You need a compact, budget-friendly smart display
• You want a bedside alarm clock with Alexa functionality
• You don’t prioritize video calls or rich audio

Choose the Echo Show 8 if:

• You want a better display, stronger sound, and high-quality camera
• You frequently make video calls
• You plan to stream media or control a smart home hub visually

In short, Echo Show 5 is a great starter device, but Echo Show 8 is the smarter investment if you want more performance, media, and communication features.

FAQs

Is the Echo Show 8 worth the extra cost over the 5?
Yes—if you plan to use it for video calls, streaming, or audio, the added value justifies the higher price.

Can I watch Netflix on both devices?
Yes, both support Netflix, Prime Video, and other streaming apps. But the experience is better on the Echo Show 8 due to the larger, higher-resolution screen.

Do both support Alexa routines and smart home control?
Absolutely. Alexa features are nearly identical across both models.

amazon echo show 5 vs 8

By understanding your priorities—space, budget, media, or communication—you can make the right choice between the Amazon Echo Show 5 vs 8. Both are excellent Alexa-powered displays, but one may fit your life just a bit better.